Superstore
AUCTIONS
Autostock
NASCAR has typically frowned upon using a vehicle for retaliation purposes.

Head2Head: Standard for retaliation repercussions

By NASCAR.COM
April 21, 2009
05:17 PM EDT
Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
type size: + -

The evidence was clear, right there before the cameras rolling live during the FOX broadcast of Saturday night's Cup race at Phoenix.

It happened like this:
Casey Mears got loose and hit Dale Earnhardt Jr., spinning him out.
• Earnhardt caught Mears on the cool-down lap and spun him out.
• Mears caught Earnhardt on pit road and tapped his rear bumper.

Watch it all unfold

As a result, NASCAR placed both drivers on a six-race probation, beginning this weekend at Talladega (read more).

The focus isn't on whether Mears' initial hit was intentional; video replays show his car wiggled and moved up into Junior's. But the cool-down-lap retaliation sparks a debate on whether NASCAR should have standard repercussions if a driver uses his car to voice displeasure.

Read both sides of the argument, then weigh in with your take.external link

Should NASCAR have a standard penalty for retaliation?

YES NO

It doesn't happen very often -- retaliation once the race ends -- but if NASCAR wants to show it is credible and doesn't want drivers taking the law into their own hands, now is the time for officials to set a firm penalty on the cool-down spinout.

We saw the move Saturday night in Phoenix when Dale Earnhardt Jr. let Casey Mears know how unhappy he was by clipping the No. 07 and sending him around. It was intentional, it was blatant, it was dangerous, and it was wrong.

It's not like this is an isolated thing. Every year there are a handful of incidents once the race ends, and NASCAR needs to nip them in the bud.

It's simple -- a driver can't be judge and jury. He might be mad about an on-track incident but that does not give him the right to crash the other driver -- even if it's on the cool-down lap when it's not as dangerous as during the race.

If a pitcher retaliates in baseball, he's shown the showers. NASCAR needs its own set penalty.

It costs a driver 100 points if alterations are found on the new car -- blatant or not. So a 50-point penalty for any post-race incident with a vehicle I think is sufficient.

I know fans love the drama; they like to see the personalities of the drivers. But these need to stop before it gets out of control. A driver may be upset with another, but they CANNOT be allowed to use their car as the voice of their frustration.

Bill Kimm, NASCAR.COM

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

After what seemed like an eternity, fans finally got what they wanted Saturday night in Phoenix. No, I'm not referring to Mark Martin's first win since 2005 (although many wanted that as well). I'm talking about drivers showing some emotion.

The pressure has been mounting for Dale Earnhardt Jr. While his teammates visit Victory Lane and dominate the points, it was another race for the most popular driver, another pit problem, another car not to his liking, another lead vaporized.

To make matters worse, he got kicked while he was down by Casey Mears -- intentionally or not. The result: another finish of 20th or worse, his fourth of the season. He's tired of making excuses and he's as mad as a NASCAR purist forced to watch a Digger cartoon ... so he delivers payback.

Junior hit Mears at a snail's pace and nowhere near the driver's side door. Mears suffered minimal damage and he returned the favor. In my mind, it's a wash. If it happened at higher speeds or drivers, officials or crewmen were put at risk, I'd recommend a stiff penalty. In this case, they made their peace, nobody was in jeopardy of getting hurt, and they provided some excitement.

In NASCAR's heyday, punches were thrown without consequence. Let's not get bent out of shape over a little wrinkled sheet metal. Darrell Waltrip recently begged for more passion and fans have been craving it. Junior and Mears delivered. Let's not punish them for it.

Jason Schoellen, NASCAR.COM

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

The End

POPULAR ALERTS
or Create Your Own

Poll

Whose argument do you agree with the most?
Bill Kimm
Jason Schoellen
view results

Remember To Check Out

All External sites will open in a new browser window. NASCAR.COM does not endorse external sites.
© 2001-2009 NASCAR | Turner Sports Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Turner Entertainment Digital Network NASCAR.COM is part of the Turner Sports and Entertainment Digital Network.